JTrubsI have the full size Urban Trapper which I love for carrying when I need something classier in appearance. I don't think I would ever EDC it, I just don't see a VG10 knife beating out others that I have that are more suited for "harder" use.
Back to my original question, as far as size and feel in the hand how does the UT compare to a full size Kwaiken? I like the looks of the Kwaiken, not as much as the UT which is why I went with the UT initially.
namhodUnfortunately, I can't really shed any light on your question in regards to the full-size versions of the UT compared to the Kwaiken; I have only the mini versions of each. I can tell you that as discreet "gentleman's" knives I like the mini versions of both very much. I prefer the blade shape of the UT but I find the Kwaiken to have a slightly better and more elegant design, and it's a little smoother to open. Perhaps that might translate the same to the full-size versions?
As far as the durability of VG-10 compared to other steels, there's usually some trade-off when it comes to the various traits of these steels (edge retention, ease of sharpening, corrosion resistance, etc), and I don't know what other blades you have in your knife locker. My regular EDC for the past 20+ years has been an ATS-34 bladed Benchmade; technically not quite as tough as VG-10. But I've been beating the holy hell out of it for more than two decades and the blade is still in good shape, shaving sharp, and has never failed me when I've needed it. Granted, I maintain it fairly well but I suppose I'm trying to say that it's not always in the numbers you see on paper. My 2 cents and your mileage may vary. Cheers!
namhodI have both and the difference is that kwaiken has a considerably thicker blade and thick steel liners. It's much more heavy. My urban trapper doesn't have any scales on top of titanium, maybe a layer of carbon or g10 composite fiber on top could give it some rigidity, but even pinching the frame between my fingers I can have titanium frame bend a lot. I could probably rip the blade out of my urban trapper if I wanted to just by bending it out of the way, its titanium has a lot of give.
Kwaiken has none of that flimsiness, it feels like a solid piece of steel that it is. It's more than twice the weight of the urban trapper. I suspect that this is intentional part of a design, it can certainly be used as an impact weapon when folded due to its heft and shape. It's much more similar in feel and apparent design intentions to a crkt vizzle than an urban trapper.
Back to my original question, as far as size and feel in the hand how does the UT compare to a full size Kwaiken? I like the looks of the Kwaiken, not as much as the UT which is why I went with the UT initially.
As far as the durability of VG-10 compared to other steels, there's usually some trade-off when it comes to the various traits of these steels (edge retention, ease of sharpening, corrosion resistance, etc), and I don't know what other blades you have in your knife locker. My regular EDC for the past 20+ years has been an ATS-34 bladed Benchmade; technically not quite as tough as VG-10. But I've been beating the holy hell out of it for more than two decades and the blade is still in good shape, shaving sharp, and has never failed me when I've needed it. Granted, I maintain it fairly well but I suppose I'm trying to say that it's not always in the numbers you see on paper. My 2 cents and your mileage may vary. Cheers!