I went with the pebbled grain one and quite like it. My strap is well made and had no scratches. All the holes were perfectly punched and the width was right on.
I can only note two issues:
1. My metal keeper is crooked as some others have noted. I can't really straighten it as the stitching is too tight, but it is minor and on the bottom of my wrist. At some level, I like it as it will remind me that it was handmade.
2. Massdrop: Please do not fold my cordovan strap in the shipping package! I know cordovan is crease resistant, but still (it's a nice cordovan strap!!!) get a longer bag or roll it up!
Overall, a very nice strap though.
Overall, a very nice strap though.