Torn between a size 11.5US (EE) /11UK (F) or 12US (EE) /11.5UK (F). I bought the magnolia in the 11US (D) /10.5UK (E) width in the last drop and it was too narrow and tight in the toe cap area that i couldn't keep it.
For reference, I also bought the faunterleroy single monk strap size 10.5UK (D) in the last drop and that fit true to my size.
What size would you recommend?
TheShoeSnob2 Septieme Larguer Oxfords, Size UK11, Last 224/ 206, Width E (Their widest Width size, and they both fit true to my size)
Crockett and Jones (Cavendish Suede Loafers), Last - No 325, Size UK10.5 Width E (Perfect Fit)
Alden Shell Cordovan Size US11.5 Width E, Last 684 (A little Roomy, slips off at times from the back because of how long it is, but nevertheless Very good fit Width wise)
Fauntleroy Single Monk Size, UK10.5 (true to size, maybe slightly narrow after extended usage but simply readjust the strap for looser fit.)
Overall, i believe I'm a US11.5/UK11 size when there is a wide width (EE/F) in the toe cap. However, the Magnolia UK10.5 was so narrow compared to the Fauntleroy UK10.5. I question wheather a larger width size and a .5 up is enough. @TheShoeSnob
Stan95Our shoes are not on the correlation of uk11 is us11.5. Our uk11 is a US12. Based on all that you write, while slightly confused by your Cavendish size, I would say that you will need either uk10.5F or UK11E. A UK11F will be too big for sure. But between those two I cannot say which one will fit you better.
For reference, I also bought the faunterleroy single monk strap size 10.5UK (D) in the last drop and that fit true to my size.
What size would you recommend?