Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions
rmvs
17
Aug 1, 2017
Will photos of physical samples be available? The renders contain several shades, the yellow and supernova in particular that are out of gamut of many physical color processes -- I'm not confident that the renders are accurate or even possible.
I would have also liked to see "white" legends ala SA Godspeed, and I think the typeface change and rounded art clash with the vintage ideology of honoring Apollo 11, something that made SA Godspeed an instant classic.
MiTo
13955
MiTo
Aug 1, 2017
rmvs> The renders contain several shades, the yellow and supernova in particular that are out of gamut of many physical color processes.
Renders do not contain several shades, they are Pantones used on Canvas. Colors will be manually adjusted (if needed) once I receive my samples but I'm pleased with the colors I've seen so far (Canvas). Despite not being a 100% match with Canvas, because batches of resin vary from batch to batch, they should be similar. The yellow and blue tones rendered on the kits are nearly identical to this Canvas shot. The blue is slightly more washed in real life then this picture shows. Yellow is slightly more vibrant. This color argument always happen, people's monitors vary and other factors take place, but I trust my judgement. You can be sure the final product will look better than the renders!
search

> I would have also liked to see "white" legends ala SA Godspeed
Current manufacturing techniques that exist do not allow that. White legends can't be dye sublimated on PBT plastic.
> typeface change and rounded art clash with the vintage ideology of honoring Apollo 11, something that made SA Godspeed an instant classic.
Appreciate the feedback and that you enjoy the Godspeed keycaps, the typeface used here is nearly identical to the one used on Godspeed, only slightly smaller.
rmvs
17
Aug 8, 2017
MiToThank you for posting the Canvas photo, it looks much better than the XDA Godspeed renders. If you think they're accurate or close, you should put them on the main page.
However...
>Renders do not contain several shades, they are Pantones used on Canvas.
Actually they do -- due to the light and shadows in the render, the keys are a range of color values, and most if not all of the entire range is out of the Pantone gamut. This can easily be verified with Photoshop or other software licenced for Pantone repro and is independent of monitor calibration. The base material used in the software may be the correct color values or close, but the fast/basic render settings (it may be a program limitation) yield inaccurate renders. I'm happy to recommend settings if you let me know what software you're using.
I think you missed my main question: Will photos of physical samples be available before the drop ends?
Please understand that I'm a big fan -- I respect you, your work, and all that you've done for for the community. I'm willing to back these keys and while they are a good price compared to other sets, many of our wallets will still feel the hit -- I think it's only fair to ask for truly accurate sample shots in a pricey medium where color is of the utmost importance.
MiTo
13955
MiTo
Aug 8, 2017
rmvsI'm not questioning you or saying that what you asking is not fair. Godspeed is the first ever keyset to feature a full sample of any sort before production, there's a typeface sample on my top post. That's not the norm. Look at other keysets drops, no samples exist.
Can't guarantee that "accurate sample photos" will be shared before the drop, I don't have those yet. If you don't trust my judgement, then avoid the buy. But as you can see, like you said, Canvas photos look better than renders, I have experience in this craft and I know what I'm doing. The product you'll receive will be pristine.
MiToYes, but will it get me to the Moon? That's the real question here...
MiTo
13955
MiTo
Aug 8, 2017
BecauseRacecarNot only to the Moon but to Mars, also.
MiToWell, now you're just being ridiculous. How will I make it home for dinner!?
MiTo
13955
MiTo
Aug 8, 2017
BecauseRacecarYou won't, might as well start planting potatoes.
MiTo......
Well played, MiTo. Well played indeed.
MiToAh, The Martian. What a great book.
PRODUCTS YOU MAY LIKE
Trending Posts in Mechanical Keyboards