Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions
Showing 1 of 575 conversations about:
hatman
362
Jun 1, 2017
bookmark_border
After reading the review solicited by NuForce for this drop, I still don't know how these earphones that no one has heard of sound.
Here's how the reviewer describes his first sample:
"I have to admit that the review sample I got ended up being a disappointment due to the sound being overly bassy with no treble. Even with 1 week of driver blasting I thought the guys at Massdrop went over the edge. The sound was terrible. I told them if this is what they have planned for a big release then I questioned their direction. My concerns was quickly met by them overnighting a confirmed good sample. Long story short. The newer sample I got was in deed a different beast! "
Right there is where the reviewer should have said -- this is a red flag, dear consumer, proceed with caution.
What happened between the first sample and the second? No explanation. Would your purchase sound like the first or the second? Who knows?
The reviewer does tell us that, " Disclaimer: No Chinese food was wasted ..." He thinks he is a clever writer. Sadly, this kind of opinion writing does little to enlighten us.
These could be terrific-sounding earphones; we'll never know from this writeup.
In his profile, the writer describes his occupation as, I kid you not -- "Mess with people." Maybe he does that as well with his "reviews."
Jun 1, 2017
JamesX
552
Jun 1, 2017
bookmark_border
hatmanThey already have a signature or direction for this IEM:
"The result is a thoroughly enjoyable listening experience: spacious, detailed, musical, and coherent, with a bit of extra bass that doesn’t take away from the overall balance. "
So if they allow these "enthusiasts" to turn everything neutral despite the description reading "bassy" then I would return them.
Jun 1, 2017
Dsnuts
117
Jun 1, 2017
bookmark_border
hatmanSorry if I came across as not being so serious with the review. This is my style of portraying the sound but I am very serious about my sound. I have been using these earphones ever since I got the good review unit. The bad unit was from a bad batch as I know another reviewer who got a very similar sounding bad unit for review.
It does surprise me that they wont ship till October. The sound is very worthy of purchasing. Even though I may come off as a goof ball I am very serious about my sound. I have done many reviews for NuForce and lead an active roll on headfi.org.
I can get into the sound a bit more later but you and others will have to trust that these guys know what they are doing with these IEMs.
Jun 1, 2017
hatman
362
Jun 1, 2017
bookmark_border
DsnutsThank you for your comments, Dsnuts. No offense intended.
I'm sure that the folks at NuForce know exactly what they are doing. But there are many flavors of IEMs aimed at many different markets and consumers.
Which is this? We don't know -- it's a mystery IEM.
If I were marketing earphones toward a market that is more price sensitive, I would send samples to enthusiasts who might gladly give a positive review in exchange for a freeby and a chance to get more readership for his or her review.
If I were marketing earphones toward an audiophile market, I might send samples to a more established reviewer who would compare them with others of similar price. The best reviewers would even measure them.
Again, no offense. But in the absence of facts or more informed opinion, we are pretty much left to judge these by how they are being marketed.
Jun 1, 2017
Dsnuts
117
Jun 1, 2017
bookmark_border
hatmanYour right it is fair that you would want graphs and comparison to other iems. I opened an thread on Headfi.org that can get into more detail of the sound and I certainly can do comparisons for you. My observation was subjective my own take compared to many I have heard in the sub $100 category when it comes to sound. The earphones I was using before I did this review was a much more expensive Trinity Audio Master Iem which MSRPs for 3X more than the EDCs. Lets just say I was not tempted to use them once since I got the EDC for review.
These are not an analytical sounding earphone meaning they are not ruler flat or claim to be. I suppose if that is the type of sound your looking for I would look elsewhere. I did take a jab at folks that like analytical earphones on my review as I describe an analytical sound as "Skinny sound."
I would say the sound profile is more consumer oriented than audiophile but show me an audiophile that listens to tracks out in street to pick off details. These are meant to take on the road to enjoy as you shop, hike, ride a bike, or in my case drive to work. Lol.
They have a good balance between highs mids and bass, with a bit of relaxed treble for a non fatiguing sound but the real calling card on these earphones is their ability to do sub bass with almost no drop off. So I would say if your music taste is eclectic as my own which is just abuot everything that is well recorded. I would say these are excellent for their intended purpose which is using them out and about.
If you are into high amounts of precision, detail and imaging. I would look elseware. Your not going to find this with a $60 IEM but if you want to get lost in your music out and about and actually enjoy your music. Ya I would grab a pair. It is a no brainer. For all the 100s of earphones I have owned and or reviewed I have only given a 5 star review to two IEMs. My Sony Z5 and the EDC.
-Quick comparisons. Shozy Zero vs the EDC. Similar sound profile actually but Zeros are about the mids with little treble sparkle or extension and a bit flabby sub bass. I only wish they sounded as engaging as the EDCs. EDCs not only do they have comparable mids but the highs have a bit more refinement and sub bass of the EDC has authority Shozy Zero can't begin to match. EDC is clear winner here for sonic ability and both cost about the same.
Audio Techinica IM03. The ATs are actually with upgraded cable also has a similar sound balancing/ profile to the EDCs. Sure the ATs are a superior earphone but out on the street it becomes more even playing field. Here is what I meant by " You will wonder why you spent so much on your earphones." My IM03 with upgraded cable cost me almost $400. It is a 3 BA earphone but has a similar sound balancing as the EDC. Much better sound separation, detail in every part of the spectrum minus the sub bass. So you get what you pay for here in the IM03 however when I am out and about. I actually preffer the EDCs simply because they do sub bass better than the IM03 and sound just as good. Am I gonna miss the hyper detail I can get from the IM03? Nope cus I am not really listening for it out and about.
JVC FX850. One of my all time favorite IEMs. If you are serious about your audio. I highly recommend a JVC woodie to add to your collection. Again here is a superior earphone in every regard over the EDC as they should be. However out in the street. They isolate poorly so I can throw all them great sonic abilities of the FX850 out the door cuz they leak in sound as they are semi open. They are superior in every way yet don't sound superior in the library cus I can hear the person next to me chatting away even with music playing. EDC isolate much better and has enough detail and ability to reproduce any track you own the way it is supposed to sound.
The EDC is beat by a lot of earphones I own truth be told but when you take them out that is when you will appreciate what they do. I have also own other micro dynamic iems that all have solid sonic capabilities including Sony HM1C, JVC FX51, JVCFXD70, FXD80, Zero Audio Tenors, AT CKN50 and CKN70..
Believe me micro driver tech is vastly under used and when Mike at Massdrop contacted me to do this review and I found out it was a micro driver I had a good idea how they will do for sonics. They did not disappoint.
Jun 1, 2017
Ninoge
0
Jun 1, 2017
bookmark_border
DsnutsHi Dsnuts, How are the imaging and vocals? Clarity and air?
Jun 1, 2017
Dsnuts
117
Jun 1, 2017
bookmark_border
Ninogeclarity is actually solid for a single smaller driver especially with the tip mod I put on that review. It opens up the mid range a touch due to having a bit more treble and lesser mid bass from stock tips. They sound like a more semi open configuration due the single driver being housed in a much larger shell. No constrictive closed sound if that is what your worried about. It actually has a good openness to the sound which was a big surprise to me.
The sound does have a slightly warmer tilt to the tonality over a neutral tone. The treble is actually done really well here and show plenty of shimmer and sparkle when called upon but is not going to pierce your ear with it. I feel mid range does an excellent job of portraying vocals and instruments in an accurate natural way vs being over hyped or too colored in any reagion. It does female vocals really well and does male vocals even better. The tuning is a safe one but then has this awesome sub bass with crazy texture that reaches deep. Excellent sound on the go.
Jun 1, 2017
Onslash
166
Jun 2, 2017
bookmark_border
DsnutsHow does this compsre to shure 215? To beyerdynamic dx 120 ?
Jun 2, 2017
sircoolio
6
Jun 4, 2017
bookmark_border
DsnutsI'm not as massive an audiophile (said as an envious compliment) as many commenting here, but I wholeheartedly endorse the comments above on the sound signature. I'm really enjoying the balanced sound on these EDC. I thought the comments about who the target audience is are interesting, as I own both some nice audiophile gear and some "value" products. These are the best everyday carry IEMs I've experienced; they will displace the bevy of non-audiophile IEMs I've tried but I won't describe them as audiophile grade. But for most that's the point of the EDC label? Something you carry with great value and performance but if you lost it in the shuffle of every day life you wouldn't be sad or depressed because of all of the money you just lost?
Great sound for the value with perks like replaceable cables.
Jun 4, 2017
Dsnuts
117
Jun 4, 2017
bookmark_border
sircoolioCompletely agreed. Have you tried to use a small amp on yours? I was listening again with my X5iii and E12A amp last night and I found myself just enjoying the EDCs abilities to expand with more power.
I have mentioned it before and I will say it again. Wait till you guys amp the EDC. It will surprise you. These scale to more power better than most. And this why I am actively looking for a good balanced cable for the EDC. I have a very good feeling these will sound even better in balanced mode.
Jun 4, 2017
sircoolio
6
Jun 4, 2017
bookmark_border
DsnutsHaven't yet but I'll do that and report back!
Jun 4, 2017
Kciel
1
Jun 18, 2017
bookmark_border
DsnutsHi Dsnuts, Since you mentioned CKN70 which I had previously, how is the EDC in comparison? Can I still appreciate the sound even indoor? I mean relative to other IEMS in the price range
Jun 18, 2017
Dsnuts
117
Jun 18, 2017
bookmark_border
KcielA more refined CKN70 is the CKR9. In comparison the EDC does not have the sharper treble of the CKN70. I still own the CKN70 and I will use in occasion but I can't say it is a phone I use on a regular basis. Much prefer my CKR9 or better yet my CKR10. The EDC has more in common with the CKR10.
Fuller bodied sound vs the CKN70. Warmer more natural tone vs the brighter somewhat metallic tone of the CKN70. No sibilance vs the CKN70 as well. Overall sound is thicker fuller a bit more roomier, the EDC actually has the better balance between the 2 earphones. CKN70 has a bit better width of sound but not the depth of the EDC. CKN70 does detail well, better than the EDCs but at the cost of that sharper treble and is easier to drive. I would say the CKN70 was very close to being an analytical type sound signature and the EDC is much more musical and more natural easier non fatiguing sounding earphone. The EDC actually has the more versatile sound signature vs the CKN70. If you like a more brighter sound signature you might not like the EDCs.
As good as the EDC is outdoors. They actually sound better indoors. Wait till you guys try them on an amp. I will leave that up to you guys to hear for yourselves. On an amp they don't sound anything like a $60 earphone. They don't sound like earphones. Lol. All in due time. ( Definitely try my tip mod on my review I posted on Headfi.org. ) They sound better to me in every way with a wide bored tip.
Jun 18, 2017
Kciel
1
Jun 18, 2017
bookmark_border
DsnutsThanks for the response, appreciated. Well these sound promising. Think I'll join the drop :)
Jun 18, 2017
Dsnuts
117
Jun 18, 2017
bookmark_border
KcielI am certain for the money MD is asking for these it is a very safe purchase. I have much more expensive earphones that I only wish gave as much value.
The EDCs has the type of sound that might not Wow you on first listen. It is when you listen to them. And get used to them is when they grow on you. Guys will appreciate how natural the sound is.
Give them a solid burn in and try them with your favorite tracks and on all your sources.
Just a guess or a prediction on my part but I think these will become a big hit.
Jun 18, 2017
View Full Discussion
Related Products