@AndrewMason
A question for Andrew Mason, if he is still around.
Can this amp be used with a 16 ohms compression driver, in an active crossover loudspeaker setup?
The compression driver I plan to use is a 16 ohms nominal load, with a minimum of 12 ohms around 5 kHz:
https://materion.com/-/media/files/electrofusion/a_truextent_info/tds2003_bex4008_16.pdf?la=en&hash=70EDC11630FA264D86207716FF340EC4C4A24255
(impedance plot on the second page, pretty typical of a 16 ohm compression driver from JBL or TAD)
Is that too low a load?
Would the SE output be more appropriate?
Thanks!

Thank you!
I joined the drop, but I still have a few (!) questions, if you don't mind :)
1- How is THD vs frequency? Would you have a such a graph, for both high and low loads (300 ohms/16 ohms for example) at a given power?
2- Any IMD figures to share for low loads?
3- Does the amp emit a pop/thumb/noise when turned on and off, or is it completely silent?
4- Is it DC coupled, and is there any form of DC protection?
5- What is the DC offset (max and stabilized) for SE and balanced outputs with shorted inputs?
6- How long does it take for the amp to stabilize to its full potential when turned on (DC offset, distortion, etc.)
7- Would you have a curve of the output impedance vs frequency? (I see that it is approximately doubled at 1.5kHz compared to DC on the Benchmark AHB2, looking at the damping factor graph, but I don't know if this amp will share a similar behavior)
8- The specs show distortion figures for 1mW and 100mW, and then the 1% distortion point (aka max power). How does the amp behave between these two points? Any THD vs power curve to share for low and high loads? Or maybe figures at mid power (-3dB relative to the 1% THD point) at different loads? That would be most useful.
Sorry for the load (pun intended) of questions!
Thanks in advance.

Hi pospos.
1. Added to backlog. Problematic since 555 doesn't compute such low thd properly during sweeps.
2. Added to backlog.
3. No pop / thump whatsoever at turn on/off. Dead silent.
4. It's ac coupled at the input to eliminate any dc from the source / DAC, but is otherwise dc coupled throughout. It probably voids the warranty and I officially don't recommend it, but the 4 caps are right there waiting to be shorted to make it dc coupled.
5. Small dc offset. No servo. I've added this data request to the backlog.
6. Thd and dc offset stabilize within a few seconds or less. The thermal time constants are very short and the die temperatures vary very little.
7. Now you're just making work for me :)
8. AAA THD is very flat between 1mW, 100mW, and -3 dB. But! The APx555 has an issue wherein it doesn't compute such low thd properly during sweeps. We rely on fft to get accurate results. But ffts are in freq domain and the AP GUI doesn't permit moving the data to a sweep graph without using export / import functions and some manual Excel post-processing. A real pain in the butt.

Hi Andrew,
Thank you so much for taking the time to answer all those questions.
It is really priceless to have a member of the design team shim in and answer customer's questions in such a open manner!
My purpose is certainly not to cause you any unnecessary pain is the place you mention, so to simplify questions 1 and 8 a set of discrete measurements would certainly be adequate.
For example for the THD vs frequency simple measurement at 100Hz, 1kHz (already done) and 6kHz would be perfect, at different loads (300 ohms, 32 ohms, 16 ohms?)
For THD vs power a simple 1kHz measurement at say -1dB, -3dB and -10dB at the different loads already mentioned would be perfect.
Regarding the IMD measurement already published, at what power are they measured?
Thank you !

Maybe just a suggestion, de 555 doesn't compute very well during sweeps but has a very nice feature of sending a serie of discrete tones, don't have one available but it's fairly easy to find and I really like this option for stuff like THD by frequency

Hi Andrew, what about a compression driver supertweeter used in the 10kHz-20kHz range with a 4 to 5 ohms load ?
http://www.audioheritage.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?33558-045Mg-045Be&p=339108&viewfull=1#post339108
There is little power in that range, and HD is a none issue or course (albeit IMD might be).
Would you advice using the SE output in that case?
Another solution would be to use an autoformer and turn that 4 ohms load into a 32 ohms one (-9dB).
Autoformer distortion in the HF should be very low with a good unit like this one: https://www.ebay.com/itm/382404871179
What do you think?

hi @pospos . It's a tricky thing. The amp isn't designed or tested for such low impedances, even if you're driving very little power there. I mentioned the current rating too. Converting higher your effective load impedance (as seen by the amp) with a transformer would certainly take the load off the amp. Sorry, as an engineer I can't make a more definitive recommendation without testing stuff - hope you understand!

You are currently viewing a single conversation. Return to Full Discussion

Sorry for the load (pun intended) of questions!

Thanks in advance.

Thank you so much for taking the time to answer all those questions. It is really priceless to have a member of the design team shim in and answer customer's questions in such a open manner!

My purpose is certainly not to cause you any unnecessary pain is the place you mention, so to simplify questions 1 and 8 a set of discrete measurements would certainly be adequate.

For example for the THD vs frequency simple measurement at 100Hz, 1kHz (already done) and 6kHz would be perfect, at different loads (300 ohms, 32 ohms, 16 ohms?)

For THD vs power a simple 1kHz measurement at say -1dB, -3dB and -10dB at the different loads already mentioned would be perfect.

Regarding the IMD measurement already published, at what power are they measured?

Thank you !

Thanks

There is little power in that range, and HD is a none issue or course (albeit IMD might be). Would you advice using the SE output in that case?

Another solution would be to use an autoformer and turn that 4 ohms load into a 32 ohms one (-9dB). Autoformer distortion in the HF should be very low with a good unit like this one: https://www.ebay.com/itm/382404871179

What do you think?