Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions
Showing 1 of 178 conversations about:
Pramienjager
40
Apr 15, 2015
bookmark_border
I cannot understand paying this much for anything less than mechanical. I know "electro-capacitive" is good, but it is no where near the life cycle or quality of mechanical.
Apr 15, 2015
everyusernametaken
Apr 15, 2015
bookmark_border
PramienjagerMy chattering Cherry and Matias switches laugh at you
Apr 15, 2015
chromatically
13
Apr 16, 2015
bookmark_border
PramienjagerNovatouch Topre clones are rated for 60M actuations, 10M more than any Cherry MX. I'm guessing these are similar.
Apr 16, 2015
Expedited
53
Apr 17, 2015
bookmark_border
PramienjagerThat's a really big misconception.
Life cycles mean nothing...mechanical keyboards are actually very unreliable because of all the individual parts. Those Dell rubberdomes are super reliable because it only relies on one rubber sheet, and this keyboard (as well as Topre) follows the same principles, versus the possibility of having one of the 60-100+ switches failing on a Cherry keyboard. As you can imagine, there's a much higher risk for failure of a Cherry keyboard.
Some day, I'll write a more elaborate version of this answer to share with everyone, but these keyboards definitely aren't a downgrade.
Apr 17, 2015
zod000
83
Apr 17, 2015
bookmark_border
PramienjagerCapacitive keyboards like a Topre have a very long life cycle, so in that you are mistaken. That being said, these are not Topre and we can only speculate at their longevity based on their similarities.
Apr 17, 2015
farinasa
67
Apr 17, 2015
bookmark_border
ExpeditedExcept you can replace either the internals of a Cherry switch or the whole switch altogether. If a rubber dome gets ripped or worn out, it's pretty much done. Especially if the rubber domes are one continuous membrane. In this situation, Cherry boards are far more reliable in that they can be repaired.
Apr 17, 2015
H2O2
72
Apr 17, 2015
bookmark_border
PramienjagerI have to disagree with you on the quality issue. I just got a Novatouch and I can say for sure that it is equal to or greater in quality than any of the cherry mx switch based keyboards that I have. (Mx blues and browns). The feel is so much different from Cherries and I love it. It has no wobble, no feeling of mushy-ness that belong to cheap membrane keyboard land, and has such a satisfying 'thock' sound.
I do acknowledge that Cherry MX switches and clones have greater repairability. Switch die out, solder in a new one. Board completely fries, harvest the switches for new board, etc. However, I think for a majority of people that do not want to solder or open up their keyboards, a topre or clone has wonderful build quality and typing feel.
Torpre are like luxury cars, you cannot and do not want to mess with the machinery while Cherry are like suped up race cars that people have tinkered and fine tuned to their own taste and perfection.
Apr 17, 2015
Pramienjager
40
Apr 18, 2015
bookmark_border
H2O2When I mentioned quality I was speaking directly about the keys themselves, not the overall quality of the board. I am unfamiliar with this company and so have no opinion. That being said, when I mention quality, it refers primarily to life expectancy and function.
Apr 18, 2015
Expedited
53
Apr 18, 2015
bookmark_border
farinasalongevity=/=reliability
Apr 18, 2015
MTKMKI
25
May 12, 2015
bookmark_border
PramienjagerNo, In fact Topre could easily outlast cherry. No parts to break really. Nothings grinding. It's a superior design in every way really. Mechanical is archaic tech. Topre is future tech.
May 12, 2015
View Full Discussion
Related Products