Mar 5, 20182247 views

For Those Who Don't Know!

Tidal HiFi (Master) is absolutely amazing! I don't know what I was doing this whole time without this streaming service or did I finally break and gone crazy?
I'm running Schiit Wyrd -> Bifrost Multibit -> Jotunheim -> Fostex TH-X00 Ebony / Sennheiser HD6XX
Incredibly smooth sound, precise and powerful playing anything out of anything, maybe my foobar is fubar'd.
thumb_up
Kevin Lanning, CamStang, and 10 others
thumb_up12
44
remove_red_eye2.2K

Add a comment...
are you using the MQA codec? I updated my firmware on my iFi Micro iDSD and personally I do hear a nice improvement.
I have both Tidal and Spotify on my desktop headphone setup. Tidal sounds much better, and I believe this is largely because the Tidal application lets me set the audio output to Exclusive mode for my DAC. Spotify doesn't have this option, but if it did, I'm betting the difference in sound quality would not be as pronounced (because I know for sure that some of the music I listen to on Tidal is not CD quality - it's 320kbs AAC). I don't know of a way to make Spotify use Exclusive mode with a connected USB DAC.

I keep Spotify around, mainly because Spotify has done a lot towards recommending new music that I actually *like*, and my music library has grown because of it. Tidal only ever recommends Jay-Z.
I tried Tidal but didn't like it. Clunky UI, constant streaming issues, and the fact that Jay Z uses it as a marketing vehicle made me go back to Spotify.
riseuplight
Same.
I thoroughly enjoy my Tidal HiFi subscription for at home use. I use Google Music on the go though to save on data.
CamStang
U can actually select normal, high and hifi In the app to save data. I think normal is 128 kbps, high is 320 kbps.
Ive been using Tidal for more than 2 years now and I do agree that the sound quality is indeed unmatched as far as music streaming services go. However the UI on both the Android and PC apps is a mess and needs to be fixed. Mind you the Android app has been vastly improving but is still not on the same level as Spotify for fluidity, ease of navigation, and general speed.
Concur Tidal HiFi is very good as long (as you have an unlimited data plan)
I had a subscription to Spotify. I also have Amazon's Music Service (I don't use it). I gave a trial run to Tidal and instantly canceled my Spotify subscription and turned over to Tidal. There is absolutely a sound quality difference for most of the music - the exceptions being recordings that weren't high quality to begin with.

Now, there are definitely downsides. The absolute biggest downside as far as I'm concerned is the playlists. Spotify has that aspect down, the more music you listen to the more it knows songs you'll enjoy hearing. I love that. Tidal doesn't have anything comparable. You can choose a playlist based on genre or put together by other people, but it is never based on what you've been listening to.

Ultimately, though, the added sound quality matters to me more than the user based custom playlists. Some of the songs I've listened to in Mastered quality have made me feel like I was listening to a song I had never heard before, even if it was one I had heard hundreds of times.
NUtsid
Correct on all counts, Tidal sucks,, but the quality and a large library are the only things that saves it right now, so somebody please acquire it away from J-Z, the most annoying-all-engulfing-suffocating-all about-me-and-only-me-aspect-of-Tidal, and fix it.

The artist radio selections can be amusing for a while, and then you are hitting the next arrow... again... again... millennials picking or some zonked out ai? I have put in Buffalo Springfield and it eventually once went to J-Z... how is that? ;)

Don't say Deezer, not buying into another device-centric closed, coded system, just for HiFi, the So-Nos, Bangher&Off, Tuningfork and Moonies etc. crowd... sorry, not buying into another cage/box...

Spotify, you are playing with it, just do it, or buy Tidal, and, oh, $10/month, get the world (a lot anyway) to buy in, you will make plenty...
Tidal is a mixed bag to me. Sure, it sounds better while blind A-B comparing it against, say, Google Music with most typically giving (from my perception) a larger sound stage to the music I am listening to. However, there are also drawbacks.

1. Primarily that they don't have enough bandwidth/ server speed to maintain quality streams while under load. If anything causes me to _not_ maintain the service this will be it, but it isn't the only problem either.
2. The UI is clunky. The keyboard shortcuts that exist aren't as responsive as I would like, and they are missing some very basic but useful ones that I would like to have.
3. The queue doesn't act like a queue. When I "add X to queue" it should be at the bottom of the queue, not set to play next. Queues are FIFO (first-in-first-out) for a reason!
4. Playlist/ favorites/ music management is lacking to say the least. They basically just give it to you as albums, songs, or artists and it is up to you to sift through everything you have put together to find what you are looking for. It is easier to just search for what you want in most cases.

Now, in comparison, Google Music does all of the above significantly better, but trades off in that they don't give you lossless music. The best you can get is 320kbps, which in comparison sounds compressed (sound stage-wise), is missing some of the highs/ lows, and has a tendency to muddy some of the sound... I am possibly not explaining that last one properly, but there will be times where vocals simply drown out the rest of the audio that _should_ be playing at the same time. It is like they put their music through an equalizer to make it sound good to the "masses"; just like electronics stores run the equipment they want to sell "hot" (higher contrast, brighter, etc.) to make it look better when compared to the other equipment around it.

It is also worth noting that my gear isn't currently the most expensive out there, so I am hoping that as I get some better gear I will continue to find new ways that Tidal is better than Google Music and (with any luck) solidify whether I maintain my Tidal subscription (one way or the other).
I tried a trial membership but ended it as I heard (not through Tidal, had to do some digging) that they don't stream the higher resolution music to Tidal on DAPs, only to the "home" version... I wanted it for portable use. That said this was September or October of last year, so perhaps things have changed.
geemoneybe
i subscribe to tidal and i stream high quality portable to my note 8, oh i guess i should throw in that tidal gives military discounts on subscriptions..
I subscribed Tidal a couple years ago and set it for the High Quality setting. Maybe I have hearing problems, it seems to be compressed. Have Poweramp installed on both of my phones which play hi-resolution audio and have hi-resolution headphones, playing songs thru Poweramp is far superior than streaming thru Tidal. It's was not even close. Cancelled my subscription.
Deezer>tidal
Load 2 more comments
Tidal is a terrible company, their support is basically non-existent. Any alternatives are very welcome. I'll check it out. Thanks!
jasonnugent
More than once I've heard instruments on a track that I've never heard before. Do the 30 day free trial and give it the test!
I'm shopping, as they say for one of these services, but along the way I've found numerous sites showing studies that indicate very few people can distinguish the quality from one level to the next, or one service to the next. I have no interest in buying Kool-aid at any price! Are they all BS, or is there really a clear winner? PS: my tastes are decidedly not hip-hop. Looking for better Jazz, Blues, Acoustic, and Rock (real Rock thank you) products.
What say you?
RayF
I can assure you there is a huge margin of difference between tidal and for iex. spotify. Ofcourse this is noticable on the EPs that have great mastering. There is tons of crap which sounds just meh from wherever you tune into regardless of stream quality. But if you have decent geat you will have no trouble hearing the difference on your favourite albums. Unfortunately I do not know of another proper hifi streaming service to recommend - if there was I would have probably jumped ship myself (I have my own personal grievances with tidal, mainly the buggy and impractical UI / no real library management system / lack of proper genre tags, etc). If we want something better I guess we will have to wait until spotify jumps on the hifi bandwagon which im sure they will eventually.
Google music streaming to chromecast , using the digital optical out to my OL DAC.... This sounds CD quality to me. I have trouble telling the difference between CDs and this using the HD 600s. I doubt Tidal would sound better, but I'd be willing to try it I guess.