To negotiate the best possible price for our customers, we agree to hide prices prior to logging in.
1K requests
Product Description
Both of these Vargo knives are made from Japanese titanium alloy, a material that’s stronger and harder than pure titanium, and offers better edge retention without the use of a carbide coating. Each has a wharncliffe design for excellent point control and cutting power, and a light-sleek design that weighs just 1 ounce Read More
I assume this is mostly for pairing with everyones titanium sporks? I don't really understand the niche this fills. You can get a decent knife that only weighs a few ounces more for around this price.
Someone explain this to my simple self. I am genuinely interested, not trying to be negative about the product.
There's a lot of interesting discussion about this from our poll page: https://www.massdrop.com/vote/ultralight-titanium-knife/talk
Summary:
PROS:
Demuredemeanor said:
While certainly a good notice for those who are newer to knives, I personally like the idea of a titanium knife for their use in marine environments; salt water and sea side knife use can make for constant cleaning.
tskiller said:
Titanium isn't about hardness, its about weight. The Izula is almost three times as heavy as the Vargo or DFK. If you are a backpacker and going ultralight, every gram matters.
Chrome said:
Pending the results of the poll, I'm perfectly willing to take on a high-maintenance knife edge. I won't have to worry about rust, and I have the benefit of a nice diamond wheel sharpener at home that produces results I'm entirely pleased with.
Lepepwerdna said:
Titanium carbide / nitride is very hard: ~9 on the Mohs scale. This is approximately equal to sapphire. Diamond is 10 for reference. This is also much harder than most steels when hardened. This is why Carbides / nitrides are used in cutting tools for working hard metals such as steel. Most knife blades will have a Rockwell hardness between 50-60, this is about equal to 3-3.5 on the Mohs scale.
CONS:
Connguy said:
Titanium is a very strong metal, but not remotely as hard as modern steel (strength != hardness). This means it makes a very poor choice for a knife, because it can't hold an edge
Toxic said:
True. A pure titanium is pretty soft, so in order to make it harder, alloys are used (the most common is 6AL4V). But even best alloys can't compete with steel in hardness (which is main requirement for a cutting edge material). Even chemically hardened titanium alloys are inferior to decent steel.
Synthful said:
It's also quite brittle. The allure of a Ti knife isn't it's functionality, it's the weight and feel. In essence, it's a collector's knife. You could use it here and there, but mostly it will just be a talking piece.
Hm, I would think that titanium, as a softer metal (by volume) would loose it's edge rather quickly. To clarify what I mean by volume, titanium is 40% stronger than steel by weight, but is less strong than steel by volume. This is caused because titanium is much lighter than steel, and thus acquires it's reputation as a stronger metal, even though it is weaker, in these sense that with two equally sized bars one of titanium, and one of steel, the titanium bar will bend easier, but be lighter.
So I guess if you don't need a super-sharp knife this would be a good option, and I might buy it because how often do you need a razor-sharp blade?
VexsYup, I wrote that in the poll. Good steel blade has hardness of 58-60. This one is only 50 (and this is probably already hardest Ti alloy - Al6V4, pure Ti is even softer). So you can slice this knife with a hard steel blade :)
They had my attention until I saw it was only hardened to Rockwell C 50. I didn't know they even made a knife that soft. You would spend all your time sharpening it. I will stick with my 1.8 oz Leatherman Micra keychain multi tool.
Rory_DudleyThey don't make steel knives that soft; this is the limitation of working with titanium. Titanium is strong, but not hard. Certainly not hard enough to make a good blade.
JonasOPretty sure I've had some steel that soft... Think they were stamped as "Pakistan Steel" lol
But, seriously, this is ridiculously gimmicky. There's no need for a titanium blade that can't hold an edge, I don't care if you are one of these 'ultralight' fanatics... That's a dumb place to try to save yourself an ounce
I got the fixed blade one. I was worried about the corrosion resistance of the clip on the knife and rivets of the sheath. I've had the them soaking in salt water for about 3 weeks occasionally taking them out to let them dry. Everything looks good.
I purchased the folder version last time it was on here. It didnt come super sharp and I dont feel comfortable sharpening it. It is very light though. In terms of quality, it's meh imo. The liner lock is somewhat hard to work with, the knife isnt very smooth opening/closing. It's become more of a novelty knife for me, wouldnt really use it in everyday type of situations. For the price, if you are wanting a knife that you can actually use then I would keep looking.
Also, there are some titanium knives that are "carbidized." This means a layer of tungsten carbide is laid down along one or both sides of the edge. Tungsten carbide being harder than any conventional steel, it turns the titanium into a slicing monster. When done along one side of the edge, it actually becomes self-sharpening when cutting abrasive (and normally edge-destroying) materials like cardboard - as the titanium wears away, fresh carbide is exposed. The hard/brittle carbide combined with the soft/tough titanium produces a great light-use slicer - you won't go shopping any logs with it, but you can expect it to last indefinitely through light tasks.
I'm working on a DIY solution to carbidize this knife (assuming the drop still happens.) If not, there are a few knifemakers out there who produce carbidized Ti knives. Daniel Fairly is the first that comes to mind. We might be able to find one who can produce in volume, or maybe even get these modified en masse in a special drop.
kennyjActually, really want to like this knife... Love that it's ti, especially the single bevel. Would make sharpening a BREEZE...
But the clip looks like it's in a spot that would just get in the way and be uncomfortable while sitting in the hand... So, sorry but I'll pass guess.
HRC applies just fine. If they listed the Rockwell B hardness, most people would be even more confused since other knives all have their hardness listed as Rockwell C. That being said, I highly question that this is even 50 Rockwell C. Beta-C titanium which is one of only a few truly hardenable Ti alloys can't even reach that high on the scale and usually tops out at about 46.
iwendtAgreed. My problem with C-scale is that HRC50 measured on Titanium is not the same as HRC50 measured on steel. Steel would be noticeably more resilient in that case. And I also read about Ti alloys reaching 43-46 HRC at best.
Does anyone have experience sharpening this knife? I know that since it's titanium it won't hold an edge for long but that doesn't bother me too much if it can take a good edge when I go to sharpen it... unfortunately I have heard people say that titanium can't get much sharper than a door wedge but I don't have any other source to validate that information.
AubrealThat's not the case. While it won't hold the edge for very long, nowhere near as long as a half-decent steel blade will, it can be easily sharpened to a shaving edge.
Source: I'm a knifemaker that's been making titanium knives for over a decade.