Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions
Stepbystep
549
Jun 17, 2018
bookmark_border
I don't want to take away from an otherwise well written article but I think it's irresponsible to make the statements in the entry line and first section. Just remove those bits entirely and add some of what's in the comment here below about maps still being an essential skill, imho. You don't need to state a case for the main topic and content of the article or do any convincing that it has value, just present the facts and methods in this tutorial. Lengthened considerably, you could support statements and explore sides/issues to make it more useful, but keeping it short as is, those statements are poor. Also, it's a weak statement to suggest that "thru hikes" are any more or less challenging, navigationally speaking, than shorter trips anywhere else around the country - just depends on the trail and local land managers/trail groups. Call it how to use caltopo and avenza for navigation since it is focused only on that.
I don't want to sound like a grumpy grandpa here, but we should Never Ever discourage people from a) carrying a paper map (as primary tool or backup) or b) learning and practicing those very basic analog navigational skills. Ever. Rather, go ahead and encourage people to do that, so they are not handicapped in the event of loss, damage, other failure, or inability to get a satellite fix. With analog skills you are better prepared overall and perhaps can still make use of e-helpers even without a sat fix (that does happen you know) or, say, when the compass hardware in the phone is inaccurate (if it even has it, many do not). For phones that do still have compass hardware, most are notoriously bad, perhaps only giving a semi-solid indication of North but getting wonky as a user points in other directions, and calibration often does not fix it or only does so temporarily. Compass hardware has mostly gone the way of FM radio reception as included features. Many of us grew up with analog skills and are confident in our navigation methods and techniques, and now enjoy some of the ease and benefits of e-helpers, but you gotta remember that this site, niche as it is, still reaches a broad audience. A ton of people who will bother to read this topic are most likely noobs who do not yet have any navigational skills. Plenty of stories every year about babes in the wilderness getting lost and unable to figure out their predicament because they just never bothered to learn before diving in to the hobby - I recall a couple of them that had paper maps and a compass along (because "they were supposed to") but didn't have a clue how to benefit from them, so when their phones failed they were out of luck even though they had what they needed.
Jun 17, 2018
jonathanstull
43
Jun 18, 2018
bookmark_border
StepbystepFair points. My intent is to encourage a useful alternative. For those who are new to the outdoors, it’s crucial to learn those analog skills, if for no other reason than it teaches you to read the land and pay attention to your surroundings.
Thanks for the feedback.
Jun 18, 2018
View Full Discussion
Related Posts
Trending Posts in More Community Picks